She is survived by her daughter, Catherine Nightingale and husband Harold; two stepchildren, Donald Pangle, Jr. and Sandra Jackson; seven grandchildren, Emily, Cory, Katie, Kevin, Kerri Ann, Rachel and Rebecca Nightingale; step grandchildren, Skylar, Kevin, Ericka, Mark, Jessica, Christopher, Sarah and Nathan; two sisters, Charlotte J. Mousch and husband Bill and Carolyn Y. Shreve and husband Mayo; and numerous nieces and nephews. In addition to her parents, she was preceded in death by her husband Donald Leo Pangle.